ℏ² expansion of the transmission probability through a barrier

Ninety years ago, Wigner derived the leading order expansion term in ℏ² for the tunneling rate through a symmetric barrier. His derivation included two contributions: one came from the parabolic barrier, but a second term involved the fourth-order derivative of the potential at the barrier top. He left us with a challenge, which is answered in this paper, to derive the same but for an asymmetric barrier. A crucial element of the derivation is obtaining the ℏ² expansion term for the projection operator, which appears in the flux-side expression for the rate. It is also reassuring that an analytical calculation of semiclassical transition state theory (TST) reproduces the anharmonic corrections to the leading order of ℏ². The efficacy of the resulting expression is demonstrated for an Eckart barrier, leading to the conclusion that especially when considering heavy atom tunneling, one should use the expansion derived in this paper, rather than the parabolic barrier approximation. The rate expression derived here reveals how the classical TST limit is approached as a function of ℏ and, thus, provides critical insights to understand the validity of popular approximate theories, such as the classical Wigner, centroid molecular dynamics, and ring polymer molecular dynamics methods.