Lack of immunogenicity of xenogeneic DNA from porcine biomaterials

Clinically useful biomaterials are derived from xenogeneic extracellular matrices, but extensive processes often used to remove all residual DNA are detrimental to their proper biological function. We hypothesized that deliberate and repeated injection of DNA extracted from clinically implantable, xenogeneic extracellular matrices might elicit an immune response in a well-established murine model that could ultimately lead to altered extracellular matrix remodeling.

DNA was purified from unprocessed porcine extracellular matrices and processed extracellular matrices before sterilization (aseptic) and after sterilization. Groups of 10 mice were injected with these 3 purified DNAs and 3 controls: (1) DNA from E. coli; (2) DNA from unprocessed porcine extracellular matrices combined with interleukin-12 and methylated bovine serum albumin and emulsified in incomplete Freund's adjuvant; and (3) buffered saline. Immunizations occurred every 2 weeks for a total of 3 injections. Local cytokines and systemic anti-DNA antibodies were quantified 3 and 7 days after final injection.

The DNA extracted from unprocessed, aseptic, or sterilized porcine extracellular matrices failed to elicit a rejection response, and only with significant, proinflammatory adjuvant activation could such a response be seen. Without the adjuvants, biomaterial-derived DNA resulted in a mild accommodation cytokine response locally and no systemic anti-DNA antibody expression even at doses approximately 100-fold larger than would be clinically likely via extracellular matrix implantation.

The immunological safety of porcine extracellular matrix biomaterials appears not to be related to DNA residues present. Such biomaterials need not be extensively processed, likely leading to detrimental changes in their bioactivity, solely in an effort to remove the mammalian DNA.