Deconstructing "Sexual Deviance": Identifying and Empirically Examining Assumptions about "Deviant" Sexual Fantasy in...

We identify and examine three assumptions underpinning "sexual deviance" in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) of Mental Disorders: (1) the "sexual deviant" - often, "the male sex offender" - prefers "deviant," and has limited (if any) "non-deviant," sexual fantasies; (2) this differentiates them from the non-sexual-/non-offending "norm"; (3) preferred fantasies are "deviant" or "non-deviant." Adult volunteers (N = 279; equal numbers of sexual offending [SO], non-sexual offending [NSO] and non-offending [NO] men) provided anonymous descriptions of their favorite sexual thought and responses to a revised Wilson Sex Fantasy Questionnaire during a wider computerized survey of 6,289 men from prison and the community. Latent class analysis identified five types of favorite sexual thought; vaginal/oral sex with 1+ woman was commonest for SO men and the WSFQ findings supported this - challenging the first assumption. Both SO and NO men were over-represented for thought types considered "deviant" by the DSM - tempering the second assumption - although SO men were over-represented for thoughts involving children specifically. All thought types were multidimensional; none included solely elements considered "deviant" by the DSM - contesting the third assumption. Notions of the "sexual deviant" as "different"/"other" may underpin these assumptions, potentially negatively impacting research, therapy and understanding sexual crime.