A comparison of dogfish and bovine chymotrypsins

Bovine and dogfish chymotrypsins were compared to determine if chymotrypsin from a poikilothermic organism (spiny dogfish (Squalus acanthias] adapted to low temperatures possessed catalytic properties different from those of the same enzyme from a warm-blooded animal. An improved procedure was developed for isolating dogfish pancreatic chymotrypsin. The least hydrophobic and smallest substrate used, p-nitrophenyl acetate, had similar enthalpies of association (delta Ha) with both enzymes, whereas larger, more hydrophobic substrates had delta Ha values that were of opposite sign for the two enzymes. As the temperature increased, the association constants (1/Ks) for p-nitrophenyl valerate and p-nitrophenyltrimethyl acetate increased for dogfish chymotrypsin and decreased for bovine chymotrypsin, while the free energies of association (delta Ga) remained relatively constant. Acylation of chymotrypsin was 1.5-2.5 times slower in the dogfish enzyme than in the bovine enzyme except below 15 degrees C with p-nitrophenyltrimethyl acetate. delta H++ for acylation by p-nitrophenyltrimethyl acetate were 2.0 kcal/mol for the dogfish enzyme and 10.2 kcal/mol for the bovine, whereas delta H++ values were only slightly lower in the dogfish enzyme for the other two substrates. For all substrates, the deacylation rate constant (kcat) was greater with dogfish chymotrypsin than bovine. However, the free energies of activation (delta G++) for deacylation were nearly equal between the two enzymes for each of the substrates.