Side effects and compliance with low- and conventional-dose oral contraceptives among adolescents

Oral contraceptives are the most popular birth control method for teenagers, yet many teens discontinue use of these contraceptives prematurely. The need to minimize any potential long-term medical complications from the use of contraceptive hormones must be balanced with the desirability of increasing acceptance of contraceptives by adolescents. There has been concern that the use of so-called "low-dose" estrogen preparations, although decreasing the likelihood of complications, may lead to side effects that make compliance less certain. The present study comparing two commonly used oral contraceptive preparations, one low dose, one conventional dose, tests the hypothesis that among adolescents an association exists between oral contraceptive side effects and compliance. Using a double-blind crossover method, 55 sexually active adolescent females received two months each of a preparation containing 35 micrograms ethinyl estradiol and 0.5 mg norethindrone and another containing 50 micrograms mestranol and 1.0 mg norethindrone. The 50-microgram preparation was associated with fewer side effects when administered during the first two months. No differences in side effects were noted in the latter two months, but there was a slight increase in weight gain when compared with the 35-microgram preparation. The most common side effect was inter-menstrual bleeding with the 35-microgram pill. There was no documented relationship between the occurrence of side effects and compliance.