Studying Asymmetric Structure in Directed Networks by Overlapping and Non-Overlapping Models

We consider the problem of modeling and estimating communities in directed networks. Models to this problem in the previous literature always assume that the sending clusters and the receiving clusters have non-overlapping property or overlapping property simultaneously. However, previous models cannot model the directed network in which nodes in sending clusters have overlapping property, while nodes in receiving clusters have non-overlapping property, especially for the case when the number of sending clusters is no larger than that of the receiving clusters. This kind of directed network exists in the real world for its randomness, and by the fact that we have little prior knowledge of the community structure for some real-world directed networks. To study the asymmetric structure for such directed networks, we propose a flexible and identifiable Overlapping and Non-overlapping model (ONM). We also provide one model as an extension of ONM to model the directed network, with a variation in node degree. Two spectral clustering algorithms are designed to fit the models. We establish a theoretical guarantee on the estimation consistency for the algorithms under the proposed models. A small scale computer-generated directed networks are designed and conducted to support our theoretical results. Four real-world directed networks are used to illustrate the algorithms, and the results reveal the existence of highly mixed nodes and the asymmetric structure for these networks.