Ethical Approaches to Vaccine Allocation and Administration in Carceral Settings, With a Focus on Youth

COVID-19 has disproportionately impacted Americans in carceral settings and secure facilities. A disproportionate number of persons who are confined to carceral settings and secure facilities are members of racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic groups who experience a significant burden of COVID-19 morbidity and mortality. The pandemic-related disparities experienced by minoritized and detained adult populations have received national attention, but the burden of COVID-19 risk among justice-involved youth has been largely absent from these national conversations. With more than 40,000 youth in carceral settings, their COVID-19 risks and prevention needs warrant specific consideration, especially as vaccine distribution programs expand. Youth have been assigned a lower priority status in most state vaccine allocation plans, but youth in carceral settings are at increased risk compared with their peers, raising important questions about how to ethically allocate and administer vaccines to them. In this article we examine ethical issues that arise in the health care of minors in carceral settings and identify an ethical model that could be used to reconsider the allocation of COVID-19 vaccines.