Efficiency evaluation of sewage treatment plants in Delhi, India, using tolerance-based data envelope analysis

Correct and effective performance evaluation of wastewater treatment plants is a tough task because of the complex biological, physico-chemical, and biochemical processes and associated variables affecting their performance. Conventionally, the efficiency of sewage treatment plants (STPs) are obtained using some index relating pollutant removal efficiency with energy used or costs. These indicators consider only one variable at a time. This leads to incorrect assessment of efficiency, which in turn could adversely affect decision-making of the regulatory authorities. The data envelope analysis (DEA) method utilizes a Linear programming technique which can handle multiple input/output variables without requiring the cost function. This makes it an appropriate tool for assessing the relative efficiency of treatment plants. The present study assess the efficiency of 30 STPs in Delhi, India, using the tolerance-based DEA model utilizing the variable return of scale (VRS). The uncertainty was incorporated into the model using the tolerance measure. The model is solved using the "Add on" option in spreadsheet toolbox of excel solver. Results reveal that out of the 30 plants considered for the study, 6 are performing well (20%). Further, it was observed that a slight change in the input data leads to instability of the efficiency results. Lastly, the ranking is used to determine the treatment plant with best efficiency under all scenarios for the larger period of the year. Such studies will help in chalking out the best management practices that could be adopted by other regulatory authorities.