Change localization: A highly reliable and sensitive measure of capacity in visual working memory

The change detection paradigm has been a widely used approach for measuring capacity in visual working memory (WM). In this task, subjects see an array of visual items, followed by a short blank delay and a single test item. Their task is to indicate whether that test item changed relative to the item in the sample array. This task provides reliable measurements of WM capacity that exhibit robust correlations with many outcome variables of interest. Here, we offer a new variant of this task that we call "change localization." This task is closely modeled after the change detection task described above, except that the test array contains the same number of items as the sample array, and one item has always changed in each trial. The subject's task is to select the changed item in the test array. Using both color and shape stimuli, scores in the change localization task were highly correlated with those in the change detection task, suggesting that change localization taps into the same variance in WM ability. Moreover, the change localization task was far more reliable than change detection, such that only half the number of trials were required to achieve robust reliability. To further validate the approach, we replicated known effects from the literature, demonstrating that they could be detected with far fewer trials than with change detection. Thus, change localization provides a highly reliable and sensitive approach for measuring visual working memory capacity.