A Deep Learning-Based Computer Aided Detection (CAD) System for Difficult-to-Detect Brain Metastases

We sought to develop a computer-aided detection (CAD) system that optimally augments human performance, excelling especially at identifying small inconspicuous brain metastases (BMs), by training a convolutional neural network on a unique magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) data set containing subtle BMs that were not detected prospectively during routine clinical care.

Patients receiving stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for BMs at our institution from 2016 to 2018 without prior brain-directed therapy or small cell histology were eligible. For patients who underwent 2 consecutive courses of SRS, treatment planning MRIs from their initial course were reviewed for radiographic evidence of an emerging metastasis at the same location as metastases treated in their second SRS course. If present, these previously unidentified lesions were contoured and categorized as retrospectively identified metastases (RIMs). RIMs were further subcategorized according to whether they did (+DC) or did not (-DC) meet diagnostic imaging-based criteria to definitively classify them as metastases based upon their appearance in the initial MRI alone. Prospectively identified metastases (PIMs) from these patients, and from patients who only underwent a single course of SRS, were also included. An open-source convolutional neural network architecture was adapted and trained to detect both RIMs and PIMs on thin-slice, contrast-enhanced, spoiled gradient echo MRIs. Patients were randomized into 5 groups: 4 for training/cross-validation and 1 for testing.

One hundred thirty-five patients with 563 metastases, including 72 RIMS, met criteria. For the test group, CAD sensitivity was 94% for PIMs, 80% for +DC RIMs, and 79% for PIMs and +DC RIMs with diameter <3 mm, with a median of 2 false positives per patient and a Dice coefficient of 0.79.

Our CAD model, trained on a novel data set and using a single common MR sequence, demonstrated high sensitivity and specificity overall, outperforming published CAD results for small metastases and RIMs - the lesion types most in need of human performance augmentation.