Transient On- and Off-Pathway Protein Folding Intermediate States Characterized with NMR Relaxation Dispersion

The earliest events in the folding of a protein are in general poorly understood. We used NMR R₂ relaxation dispersion experiments to study transient local collapse events in the unfolded-state (U) conformational ensemble of apomyoglobin (apoMb). Local residual secondary structure (seen in regions corresponding to the A, D, E, and H helices of the folded protein) is largely unchanged over the pH range of 2.3-2.75, yet a significant pH-dependent increase in the conformational exchange contribution to the R₂ relaxation rate (R_ex) indicates that transient intramolecular contacts occur on a microsecond to millisecond time scale at pH 2.75. A comparison of ¹⁵N and ¹³CO relaxation dispersion data at pH 2.75 for residues in the A, B, G, and H regions, which participate in the earliest folding intermediates, indicates that chain collapse and secondary structure formation are rapid and concomitant. Increasingly stabilizing conditions (lower temperature, higher pH) result in the observation of a relaxation dispersion in the C, CD, and E regions of the protein, which are known to fold at later stages. Mutation of Trp14 in the A-helix region to Ala eliminates conformational exchange throughout the protein, and the mutation of hydrophobic residues in other regions results in the selective inhibition of conformational exchange in the B, G, or H regions. The R₂ dispersion data for WT apoMb at pH 2.75 and 10 °C are best fit to a four-state model ABGH ⇆ AGH ⇆ U ⇆ ABCD that includes on-pathway (AGH and ABGH) and off-pathway (ABCD) transiently folded states, both of which are required to explain the behavior of the mutant proteins. The off-pathway intermediate is destabilized at higher temperatures. Our analysis provides insights into the earliest stages of apoMb folding where the collapsing polypeptide chain samples both productive and nonproductive states with stabilized secondary structure.