Effects of Preservation and Propagation Methodology on Microcosms Derived from the Oral Microbiome

The creation of oral microcosms with reproducible composition is important for developing model systems of the oral microbiome. However, oral microbiomes vary substantially across individuals. To derive a reproducible composition from inocula sourced from different individuals, we tested whether selective conditions from cold storage and culturing in defined media would generate a reproducible community composition despite individual variations. In this pilot study, we collected dental plaque scrapings from three individuals, inoculated media under anaerobic conditions, and characterized the bacterial community compositions after cold storage and subsequent propagation in liquid media. Harvested cultures were extracted and bacterial composition was determined by 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing and the mothur pipeline. Our results show that samples from two out of three individuals clustered into a specific compositional type (termed "attractor" here). In addition, the samples from the third individual could adopt this attractor compositional type after propagation in vitro, even though its original composition did not display this type. These results indicate that simple selective environments could help create reproducible microcosms despite variation among dental plaque samples sourced from different individuals. The findings illustrate important parameters to consider for creating reproducible microcosms from the human oral microbiome.