BmHen1 is essential for eupyrene sperm development in Bombyx mori but PIWI proteins are not

In lepidopteran insects, sperm dimorphism is a remarkable feature, in which males exhibit two different types of sperms. Both sperm morphs are essential for fertilization: Eupyrene sperm carry DNA and fertilize eggs, whereas apyrene sperm, which do not have nuclei, are necessary for transport of eupyrene sperm into eggs. In this study, we showed that the gene BmHen1, which encodes a methyltransferase that modifies piRNAs, is necessary for eupyrene sperm development in the lepidopteran model insect, Bombyx mori. Loss-of-function mutants of BmHen1 of both sexes were sterile. BmHen1 female mutants laid fewer eggs than wild-type females, and the eggs laid had morphological defects. Immunofluorescence analysis of BmHen1 male mutants revealed that nuclei formation in the eupyrene sperm was defective, whereas apyrene sperm were normal. In mice, worms, and flies, the components in piRNA biogenesis pathway play an important role in gonad development; therefore, we constructed mutations in genes encoding core elements in the piRNA biogenesis pathway, Siwi, and BmAgo3. To our surprise, no obvious phenotypes were observed in the male reproduction system in the Siwi and BmAgo3 mutants, which demonstrated that sperm development in B. mori does not depend on piRNAs. As the sperm development phenotype in BmHen1 mutants mimics the phenotype of the BmPnldc1 mutants, we then performed RNA sequencing analysis of sperm bundles from both mutants. We found that the defects in eupyrene sperm resulted from dysregulation of the expression of genes involved in energy metabolism. Taken together, our findings demonstrate the crucial functions of BmHen1 in the development of eupyrene sperm and provide evidence that spermatogenesis in B. mori is PIWI-independent. Our results suggest potential targets for lepidopteran pest control and broaden our knowledge of the reproduction in this order of insects.