Heterogeneity of Airway Smooth Muscle Remodeling in Asthma

Rationale: Ventilatory defects in asthma are heterogeneous and may represent the distribution of airway smooth muscle (ASM) remodeling. Objectives: To determine the distribution of ASM remodeling in mild-severe asthma. Methods: The ASM area was measured in nine airway levels in three bronchial pathways in cases of nonfatal (n = 30) and fatal asthma (n = 20) and compared with control cases without asthma (n = 30). Correlations of ASM area within and between bronchial pathways were calculated. Asthma cases with 12 large and 12 small airways available (n = 42) were classified on the basis of the presence or absence of ASM remodeling (more than two SD of mean ASM area of control cases, n = 86) in the large or small airway or both. Measurements and Main Results: ASM remodeling varied widely within and between cases of nonfatal asthma and was more widespread and confluent and more marked in fatal cases. There were weak correlations of ASM between levels within the same or separate bronchial pathways; however, predictable patterns of remodeling were not observed. Using mean data, 44% of all asthma cases were classified as having no ASM remodeling in either the large or small airway despite a three- to 10-fold increase in the number of airways with ASM remodeling and 81% of asthma cases having ASM remodeling in at least one large and small airway. Conclusions: ASM remodeling is related to asthma severity but is heterogeneous within and between individuals and may contribute to the heterogeneous functional defects observed in asthma. These findings support the need for patient-specific targeting of ASM remodeling.