Evaluation of co-testing with cytology and human papillomavirus testing in cervical screening

Cervical screening is increasingly switching to human papillomavirus (HPV) testing. In many settings, the switch has involved one or several co-tests (testing using both cytology and HPV) in the screening guidelines, to ensure safety. When Sweden switched to HPV testing in 2015 the guidelines included a co-test at age 41. To evaluate the effect of co-testing, we identified all 208,701 women resident in Sweden who in 2019 were 40-42 years old and thus eligible for co-testing. All cervical samples, the results of the test and of the subsequent biopsies were identified in the Swedish National Cervical Screening Registry. Out of the 10,643 women with co-testing in screening, there were 197 women with a subsequent biopsy with high-grade cervical neoplasia or worse (CIN2+). Among these 197 women, 189 had a screening test positive for both HPV and cytology, 6 women were HPV+/Cyt- and 2 women were HPV-/Cyt+. There were 7115 women with a co-test outside of the screening program. Among these, 325 women had a CIN2+ in histopathology, 290 were double positive, 13 women were cyt+/HPV-, and 11 women each were HPV+/cyt- and HPV-/Cyt-. In summary, the additional yield of CIN2+ with co-testing was 2 cases per 10,643 women as compared with 195/10,643 CIN2+ cases detected with HPV screening alone. However, for cervical samples taken outside the screening program (e.g. taken on a clinical indication) there was an increased yield (314 CIN2+ cases detected with co-testing as compared to 301 cases with HPV screening).