Sublabial Approach Versus Modified Denker's Procedure: A Comparative Study of Pre-maxillary Tissue Clearance in...

To compare the efficacy of the sublabial and modified Denker's procedure in clearance of fungal disease from the anterior wall of maxilla and the pre-maxillary area i.e. the difficult areas of maxillary sinus. A prospective observational study was conducted over a period of 2 months (April 21-June 21) in the ENT department of Sawai Man Singh hospital, Jaipur. All the patients with clinical involvement of the premaxilla or the cheek abutting the anterior wall of maxilla were included in the study population. Cases matched in both groups were subjected to debridement either by the sublabial or the modified denker's approach. Outcomes were measured by assessing the daily CRP values, post-operative DNE every 3 days after pack removal, and imaging at the end of 1 month. Repeat biopsies were performed in patients that still had persistent symptoms after getting operated on. 16 of the 60 patients (26.6%) operated on by the endoscopic approach showed evidence of residual disease on follow-up whereas only 5 patients (9.6%) in the other category had a similar outcome. Most of the recidivism was seen in the anterior maxilla. Lower rates of complications were found following debridement by the sublabial approach. Since the sublabial approach is the most direct approach for the key areas of fungal involvement of maxillary sinus, it is recommended over the modified Denker's procedure for disease clearance from pre maxilla and the anterior wall of maxillary sinus. This view is also supported by the lower rates of complications encountered following the former.