The Role of Vibrato in Group Singing: A Systematic Review

Arguably one of the most controversial features of the singing voice, especially in a choral context, is the phenomenon of vibrato. Numerous pedagogical articles, mostly written by experienced choral singers or directors, discuss the importance of vibrato, sharing anecdotal insights about its control (often advocating reduction) in choral blend and vocal health.

This systematic review aims to identify the main questions posed in the empirical study of vibrato during group singing, and how they have been addressed to date through empirical investigations.

The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses was employed for this review. The review team consisted of the two authors. A data extraction form was designed to capture information about the participants (including age, gender, music and singing experience), study methods, experimental procedures, outcome measures, and statistical findings.

Seventeen studies were included in the review and revealed that (a) relatively few empirical investigations have studied vibrato in vocal ensembles; (b) the majority focused on vibrato production rather than perception; (c) methodological approaches include Synthesis, Multi-track recordings, Stereo/Binaural recordings, and Lx/Contact recordings; and (d) the studies focused on the main themes of Adjustment, Identification, Interaction, Intonation, and Style.

With the current body of literature, it is not possible to draw general conclusions around vibrato behavior during group singing. However, the review highlights the main subareas of interest and valuable methods which have been established and through which future research can collectively shed further light on the role of vibrato in choral singing.