Inter Observer Agreement Among Radiologist and Otorhinolaryngologists on Paranasal Sinus Computed Tomography Scans in...

To evaluate inter observer agreement between Radiologist and Otorhinolaryngologists in identifying important structures and pathologies on pre operative computed tomography (CT) scans of paranasal sinus (PNS) in chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS). A retrospective review of CT scans PNS of CRS patients. Archived CT scans were evaluated by 3 observers, similarly experienced radiologist and otorhinolaryngologist and a less experienced otorhinolarygologist. The degree of intra- as well as inter observer agreement was assessed by Cohen's kappa statistics. A moderate and a fair inter observer agreement was noted among experienced radiologist and otorhinolaryngologist; & experienced experts and less experienced otorhinolaryngologist respectively. The greatest disagreements among all observers were found in superior attachment of uncinate process, optic nerve's relationship with sphenoid sinus and dehiscence of anterior ethmoid canal. The present study demonstrated a considerable inter observer variability among radiologists and otorhinolaryngologists, irrespective of their experience in the field of speciality. A few critically important structures which showed an unsatisfactory level of agreement and thus need to be sought after with more training and practice, were also identified. These included Keros type, optic nerve's location, dehiscence of anterior ethmoid artery, vidian and maxillary nerves, lamina papyracia defect, sphenoid sinus pneumatization and attachment of uncinate process. The study also emphasized the importance of inter disciplinary conferences for pre operative evaluation of sinus CT scans of CRS patients.