The superiority of Dexpanthenol or Vaseline as excipient in nasal formulations

Dexpanthenol is an ingredient in multiple topical pharmaceutical preparations thanks to its high penetration and localized concentration. It is included in many ointments or lotions for dermatological use, assisting in healing and reducing pruritus. Vaseline is a synthetic product obtained by distilling crude oil. It is commercially available in several grades. The study presented here examined how topically applied agents (dexpanthenol or vaseline) affect nasal epithelial cells in culture. In particular, the study aimed to identify any alterations to epithelial cells which might indicate toxicity.

The nasal epithelial cells used were sourced from mucosal tissue fragments left over the following septorhinoplasty on five patients not suffering from rhinosinusitis. The first step was to dissect the mucosal fragments into smaller pieces on a sterilized Petri dish. These fragments were then placed into the DMEM-F12 cell culture medium, which had been freshly prepared. The dexpanthenol and vaseline were diluted in dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) to a concentration of 5 mg/mL. The cells in the wells were exposed to varying concentrations of dexpanthenol or vaseline. The actual concentration of the test reagent to which the epithelial cells were exposed ranged from 0.15 mg/mL to 5 mg/mL. The exposure period was 24 hours. The cells were finally examined using a Leica SP5II confocal microscope. The features sought were DNA fragmentation, condensation of the nuclei, changes in the outer membrane, or cytoskeletal abnormality. These features, if present, indicate cytotoxicity.

The viability of the cultured nasal epithelial cells was unaltered by a 24-hour exposure to dexpanthenol, nor was the cellular proliferation rate affected at the level of statistical significance. There was evidence of a cytotoxic effect from exposing nasal epithelial cells to vaseline in liquid form for 24 hours. There was a reduction in cellular viability in the plates where the highest dose of vaseline (5 mg/mL) was used. Cellular viability was not affected significantly at any of the doses below 5 mg/mL.

The absence of cytotoxic effects from the application of dexpanthenol to the nasal mucosa indicates that this agent may be safely used within the nose. The cytotoxic effects of liquid vaseline observed in this trial (condensed nuclear chromatin, loss of cellular volume) indicate that this agent may be harmful when used intranasally. For patients who require nasal packing due to nose bleeds or following endoscopic sinus surgical procedures, dexpanthenol should be preferred to vaseline from the point of view of maximizing healing of a nasal injury.