Proteomics reveals that cell density could affect the efficacy of drug treatment

In vitro cell biology study plays a fundamental role in biological and drug development research, but the repeatability and accuracy of cell studies remain to be low. Various uncertainties during the cell culture process could introduce bias into drug research. In this study, we evaluate the potential effects and underlying mechanisms induced by cell number differences in the cell seeding process. Normally, drug experiments are initiated 24 h after cell seeding, and the difference in the cell number at the time of inoculation leads to the difference in cell confluence (cell density) when drug research is conducted. While cell confluence is closely related to intercellular communication, surface protein interaction, cell autocrine as well as paracrine protein expression of cells, it might have a potential impact on the effect of biological studies such as drug treatment. This study used proteomics technology to comprehensively explore the different protein expression patterns between cells with different confluences. Due to the high sensitivity and high throughput of liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) detection, it was hired to evaluate the protein expression differences of Hep3B cells with 3 different confluences (30%, 50%, and 70%). The differential expressed proteins were analyzed by the Reactome pathway and the Gene Ontology (GO) pathway. Significant differences were identified across three confluences in terms of the number of proteins identified, the protein expression pattern, and the expression level of certain KEGG pathways. We found that those proteins involved in the cell cycle pathway were differently expressed: the higher the cell confluence, the higher these proteins expressed. A cell cycle inhibitor palbociclib was selected to further verify this observation. Palbociclib in the same dose was applied to cells with different confluence, the results indicated that the growth inhibition effect of palbociclib increases along with the increasing trend of cell cycle protein expression. The result indicated that cell density did influence the effect of drug treatment. Furthermore, three other drugs, cisplatin, paclitaxel, and imatinib, were used to treat the three liver cancer cell lines Hep3B, SUN387, and MHCC97, and a similar observation was obtained that drug effect would be different when the cell confluences were different. Therefore, selecting an appropriate number of cells for plating is vitally important at the beginning of a drug study.