Mapping the deficit dimension structure of the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale

The National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) is the most frequently applied clinical rating scale for standardized assessment of neurological deficits in acute stroke in both clinical and research settings. Notwithstanding this prominent role, important questions regarding its validity remain insufficiently addressed: Investigations of the underlying dimensional structure of the NIHSS yielded inconsistent results that are largely not generalizable across studies. Neurobiological validations by linking measured deficit dimensions to brain anatomy and function are missing.

We, therefore, employ advanced machine learning to identify an optimal representation of the dimensional structure of the NIHSS across two independent and heterogeneous stroke datasets (N = 503 and N = 690). Associated lesion locations are identified by multivariate lesion-deficit mapping (LDM) and their functional relevance is profiled based on a-priori task activation meta-data analysis, to provide an independent link to the behavioural level.

A five-factor structure of the NIHSS was identified as the most robust and generalizable representation of stroke deficit dimensions across study populations, settings, and clinical phenotypes. Specifically, the identified dimensions comprised NIHSS items for (F1) left motor deficits, (F2) right motor deficits, (F3) dysarthria and facial palsy, (F4) language, and (F5) deficits in spatial attention and gaze. LDM linked four of these factors to differentially localized, eloquent neuroanatomical areas. Functional characterization of LDM results aligned with detected deficit dimensions, revealing associations with motor functions, language processing, and various functions in the perception domain.

By cross-validating machine learning in heterogeneous multi-site stroke cohorts, we report evidence on the validity of the NIHSS: We identified an overarching structure of the NISHS containing a five-dimensional representation of stroke deficits. We provide an anatomical map of the NIHSS that is of value for future applications of individualized stroke treatment and rehabilitation.

This research was supported by the National Key R&D Program of China (Grant No. 2021YFC2502200), the National Human Brain Project of China (Grant No. 2022ZD0214000)", the German Research Foundation (Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft), Project 178316478 (A1, C1, C2), and Project 454012190 of the SPP 2041, the Helmholtz Portfolio Theme "Supercomputing and Modelling for the Human Brain" and Helmholtz Imaging Platform grant NimRLS (ZT-I-PF-4-010).