Does Irrigating While Drilling Decrease Bone Damage?

Heat generated during bone drilling may be associated with thermal necrosis and direct damage, leading to complications after surgery. This preclinical study evaluates the in vivo effects of saline irrigation, drilling device type, and device sharpness on heat generation and bone damage in viable cortical bone.

Bicortical drilling of each tibial diaphysis from anesthetized research dogs was performed to evaluate temperature and bone damage using five different devices with or without saline irrigation.

Saline irrigation and sharp drill bits were associated with smaller temperature increases and less acute osteonecrosis. Conventional trocar tip Kirschner wires were associated with the largest temperature increase and the most acute osteonecrosis changes.

The use of saline irrigation during bone drilling reduces temperature change and osteonecrosis. Furthermore, we recommend that the use of dull drill bits or standard tip Kirschner wires be avoided. Lastly, drill bit design can directly contribute to bone damage during drilling.

This study provides in vivo data from a preclinical model to validate the benefits of saline irrigation and sharp drill bits during bone drilling to regulate increases in temperature and decrease associated osteonecrosis. Risk for early implant loosening and poor surgical outcome is influenced by thermal osteonecrosis of bone such that consistent use of saline irrigation, sharp drill bits, and optimized designs may have important clinical advantages. Level of Evidence: II.