From Structural Alerts to Signature Fragment Alerts: A Case Study on Pyrrolizidine Alkaloids

Even though modeling is considered a valid alternative to mutagenicity testing for substances with known structures, it can be applied for mixtures only if all of the single chemical structures are identified. Within the present work, we investigate a new avenue to exploit computational toxicology for mixtures, such as plant-based food ingredients. Indeed, considering that in the absence of toxicological information, an important early consideration is whether any substance may be genotoxic through the mutagenic mechanism of action, we tried to establish a correspondence between genotoxic structural alerts (SAs) and so-called signature fragment alerts (SFAs). Once this correspondence is established, chromatograms could be screened for chemical features associated with genotoxic alerts. Pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs), a large group of natural toxins (several of them known as genotoxic) were used as a case study because their early identification would bring significant benefits. The method was built using 56 PA pure standards, resulting in the characterization of signature fragment alerts. Finally, the approach was verified in real plant-based samples such as herbal tea and alfalfa, where the screening of signature fragment alerts allowed highlighting quickly the presence of genotoxic PAs in plant-based mixtures. Therefore, the SFA analysis can be used for risk prioritization of newly identified PAs and for their identification in mixtures, contributing to the unnecessary use of animal experimentation for genotoxicity testing.