The influence of partial union on the mechanical strength of scaphoid fractures: a finite element study

Assessment of scaphoid fracture union on computed tomography scans is not currently standardized. We investigated the extent of scaphoid waist fracture union required to withstand physiological loads in a finite element model, based on a high-resolution CT scan of a cadaveric forearm. For simulations, the scaphoid waist was partially fused at the radial and ulnar sides. A physiological load of 100 N was transmitted to the scaphoid and the minimal amount of union to maintain biomechanical stability was recorded. The orientation of the fracture plane was varied to analyse the effect on biomechanical stability. The results indicate that the scaphoid is more prone to re-fracture when healing occurs on the ulnar side, where at least 60% union is required. Union occurring from the radial side can withstand loads with as little as 25% union. In fractures more parallel to the radial axis, the scaphoid seems less resistant on the radial side, as at least 50% union is required. A quantitative CT scan analysis with the proposed cut-off values and a consistently applied clinical examination will guide the clinician as to whether mid-waist scaphoid fractures can be considered as truly united.