Detecting Vertical Root Fractures Using Modified Methylene Blue Dye: A Preliminary In Vitro Study

Diagnostically, vertical root fractures (VRFs) can be a frustrating experience for the dentist. Misdiagnosis could result in significant time and effort losses involved in erroneously intervening endodontically and/or periodontally. Certainly, diagnosing VRFs is often very difficult, and diagnoses based on speculations have led to the extraction of many salvageable teeth. This study was conducted in the radiology unit of College of Dentistry, Prince Sattam bin Abdulaziz University, between December 2021 and June 2022 to evaluate the ability to detect VRFs following the use of a novel radio-opaque dye using periapical radiographs (PARs) and cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT). After carefully inducing VRFs on extracted, single-rooted, virgin premolars (n = 26), they were assigned to control (n = 2) and experimental groups (n = 24). The fracture site of the tooth in the control group received methylene blue dye, whereas the experimental group received a novel dye. Two differently angled PARs were obtained for all the teeth, followed by a CBCT image. Three blinded investigators participated in scoring a Likert scale form with a set of questions. Inter-/intra-examiner reliability showed excellent consistency using Cronbach's alpha test. The Z-test revealed CBCT and PAR to be equally adept at detecting VRFs, with the mean values showing no statistically significant differences. The extent of the VRFs and dye penetration were significantly better when angled radiographs and axial view CBCT were evaluated. Within the limitations of this study, the dye tested showed promising initial results as an aid in radiographically detecting VRFs. The use of such minimally invasive methods is critically needed for diagnosing and managing VRFs. However, further testing should be performed prior to its clinical use.