A 'Portfolio of Model Approximations' approach to understanding invasion success with vector-borne disease

The central challenge of mathematical modeling of real-world systems is to strike an appropriate balance between insightful abstraction and detailed accuracy. Models in mathematical epidemiology frequently tend to either extreme, focusing on analytically provable boundaries in simplified, mass-action approximations, or else relying on calculated numerical solutions and computational simulation experiments to capture nuance and details specific to a particular host-disease system. We propose that there is value in an approach striking a slightly different compromise in which a detailed but analytically difficult system is modeled with careful detail, but then abstraction is applied to the results of numerical solutions to that system, rather than to the biological system itself. In this 'Portfolio of Model Approximations' approach, multiple levels of approximation are used to analyze the model at different scales of complexity. While this method has the potential to introduce error in the translation from model to model, it also has the potential to produce generalizable insight for the set of all similar systems, rather than isolated, tailored results that must be started anew for each next question. In this paper, we demonstrate this process and its value with a case study from evolutionary epidemiology. We consider a modified Susceptible-Infected-Recovered model for a vector-borne pathogen affecting two annually reproducing hosts. From observing patterns in simulations of the system and exploiting basic epidemiological properties, we construct two approximations of the model at different levels of complexity that can be treated as hypotheses about the behavior of the model. We compare the predictions of the approximations to the simulated results and discuss the trade-offs between accuracy and abstraction. We discuss the implications for this particular model, and in the context of mathematical biology in general.