Suprathel® or Mepilex® Ag for treatment of partial thickness burns in children: A case control study

Matilda Karlsson1, Ingrid Steinvall1, Moustafa Elmasry1

  • 1Department of Hand Surgery, Plastic Surgery and Burns, and Department of Biomedical and Clinical Sciences, Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden.

Insights

Suprathel® and Mepilex® Ag dressings show similar effectiveness for treating pediatric partial-thickness scalds. Both treatments resulted in comparable healing times, infection rates, and surgical interventions, indicating Suprathel® as a viable alternative.

Area of Science:

  • Pediatric Burn Care
  • Wound Management
  • Dermatology

Background:

  • Partial-thickness scalds are common pediatric injuries requiring effective wound management.
  • Current treatments include silver-impregnated dressings like Mepilex® Ag.
  • Novel dressings such as Suprathel® are being explored as alternatives.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To evaluate Suprathel® as a potential alternative to Mepilex® Ag for treating partial-thickness scalds in children.
  • To compare the clinical outcomes of Suprathel® versus Mepilex® Ag in pediatric burn patients.

Main Methods:

  • Retrospective study of 58 children with partial-thickness scalds treated between 2015-2022.
  • Comparison of outcomes between 30 children treated with Suprathel® and 28 treated with Mepilex® Ag.
  • Investigated outcomes included healing time, burn wound infection (BWI), need for operations, and dressing changes.

Main Results:

  • No significant differences were observed between Suprathel® and Mepilex® Ag groups for any outcome.
  • Similar healing within 14 days (17/30 Suprathel® vs. 15/28 Mepilex® Ag).
  • Identical rates of antibiotic use for suspected BWI (10/group) and skin grafting operations (2/group); median of four dressing changes per group.

Conclusions:

  • Suprathel® demonstrates comparable efficacy to Mepilex® Ag in managing pediatric partial-thickness scalds.
  • Both dressings yield similar healing times, infection rates, and surgical intervention needs.
  • Suprathel® presents a viable alternative treatment option for this patient population.
Abstract