Investigating Employees' Concerns and Wishes Regarding Digital Stress Management Interventions With Value Sensitive
Jasmine I Kerr1,2, Mara Naegelin1,2, Michaela Benk1,2
1Mobiliar Lab for Analytics at ETH Zurich, Department of Management, Technology, and Economics, ETH Zurich, Zürich, Switzerland.
Journal of Medical Internet Research
|April 13, 2023
Summary
Digital stress management interventions (dSMI) show promise for employee well-being, but ethical concerns regarding effectiveness and privacy must be addressed. Value Sensitive Design (VSD) can guide the ethical development of these digital health tools.
Area of Science:
- Digital Health
- Occupational Health
- Human-Computer Interaction
- Ethics in Technology
Background:
- Work-related stress imposes significant societal economic and health costs.
- Digital health interventions offer potential solutions for employee stress management.
- Ethical risks, particularly concerning big data, are often overlooked in the design of digital stress management interventions (dSMI).
Purpose of the Study:
- To apply the Value Sensitive Design (VSD) framework to identify employee values related to workplace dSMIs.
- To assess user comprehension of these values and derive requirements for ethical dSMI design.
- To bridge the gap between technological advancement and ethical considerations in digital health.
Main Methods:
- Literature search to identify values relevant to workplace dSMIs.
- Web-based study with employees of a Swiss company, using closed and open questions for quantitative and qualitative analysis.
- Application of the VSD framework to integrate ethical considerations throughout the design process.
Main Results:
- Identified values: health and well-being, privacy, autonomy, accountability, and identity.
- Employees showed moderate to high intention to use and perceived usefulness of dSMIs.
- Significant concerns were raised regarding dSMI effectiveness, potential stress amplification, and privacy, especially with machine learning monitoring.
- Novel values: integrability, user-friendliness, and digital independence emerged from qualitative analysis.
Conclusions:
- Employees are generally willing to use dSMIs, but concerns about effectiveness and privacy persist.
- Personalized dSMIs with machine learning monitoring require careful attention to privacy and accountability.
- Specific design requirements are proposed to support VSD for ethical dSMI development.
- Findings will inform future research on VSD-based interventions and ethical digital health integration.
Keywords:
digital health interventionemployee well-beingethicsmachine learningmobile phonemonitoringstressvalue sensitive design

