Can Collagen Membrane on Bone Graft Interfere with Light Transmission and Influence Tissue Neoformation During...

Objective: This study qualitatively and quantitatively evaluated the transmission of light through a collagen membrane and the consequent local bone formation in a critical bone defect in vitro and in an animal model. Background: Currently, bone substitutes and collagen membranes are used to promote new bone formation; however, when associated with photobiomodulation, biomaterials can act as a barrier, hindering the passage of light radiation to the area to be treated. Methods: Light transmittance was evaluated in vitro with a power meter and a 100 mW, 808 nm laser source with and without membrane. Twenty-four male rats received a critical surgical defect of 5 mm in diameter in the calvarial bone, subsequently a biomaterial (Bio-Oss; Geistlich^®, Switzerland) was applied, and the animals were divided into the following three groups: G1-collagen membrane and no irradiation; G2-collagen membrane and photobiomodulation (irradiation with 4 J of 808 nm); and G3-photobiomodulation (4 J) followed by a collagen membrane. Histomophometric analyses were performed at 7 and 14 days after euthanasia. Results: The membrane reduced the light transmittance (808 nm) by an average of 78%. Histomophometric analyses showed significant differences in new blood vessels on day 7 and bone neoformation on day 14. Irradiation without membrane interposition resulted in a 15% more neoformed bone compared with the control (G1), and 6.5% more bone compared with irradiation over the membrane (G2). Conclusions: The collagen membrane interferes with light penetration during photobiomodulation, decreases light dosimetry on the wound area, and interferes with bone neoformation.