Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 2, 2025
Setting Up a Stroke Team Algorithm and Conducting Simulation-based Training in the Emergency Department - A Practical Guide
Published on: January 15, 2017
Virtual trauma patient simulation design using the McGill Simulation Complexity Score (MSCS): a breakthrough in
Melina Deban1, Sameena Iqbal1, Andrew Beckett1
1From the Departments of Surgery (Deban, Beckett, Razek, Khwaja), Critical Care Medicine (Khwaja) and Nephrology (Iqbal), McGill University Health Centre; Faculty of Medicine Molson Informatics Unit (Posel, Fleiszer), McGill University, Montréal, Que.
Background:
Virtual patient simulations are interactive, computer-based cases. We designed scenarios based on the McGill Simulation Complexity Score (MSCS), a previously described objective complexity score. We aimed to establish validity of the MSCS and introduce a novel learning tool in trauma education at our institution.
Methods:
After design of an easy and difficult patient scenario, we randomized medical students and residents to each perform 1 of the 2 scenarios. We conducted a 2-way analysis of variance of training level (medical student, resident) and scenario complexity (easy, difficult) to assess their effects on virtual time, the number of steps taken in the scenario, beneficial and harmful actions, and the ratio of beneficial over harmful actions.
Results:
Virtual patient scenarios were successfully designed using the MSCS. Twenty-four medical students and 12 residents participated in the easy scenario (MSCS = 3), and 27 medical students and 12 residents did the difficult scenario (MSCS = 18). Though beneficial actions were similar between students and residents, sudents performed more harmful actions, particularly when the scenario was difficult. One virtual patient died in the easy scenario and 3 died in the difficult one (all medical students). Performance varied with level of complexity and there was significant interaction between level of training and number of steps, as well as with number of harmful actions. Decreasing performance with increasing level of complexity, as defined by the MSCS, suggests this score can accurately quantify difficulty.
Conclusion:
We established validity of the MSCS and showed its successful application on virtual patient scenario design.
