Optimal Approach to Small Unilateral Testicular Nodules-Can We Reliably Predict Tumor Histology Based on Size?

We evaluated primary testicular tumor characteristics associated with nongerm cell tumor histology and potential appropriateness for testis sparing surgery in selected patients from our institution.

We retrospectively reviewed medical records of patients undergoing surgery for testicular masses between 2003 and 2015. We included patients with unilateral testicular tumors, normal preoperative serum tumor markers and no preoperative evidence of metastatic spread. Demographic and clinical information were extracted. The primary outcome studied was tumor pathology, germ cell tumor histology vs nongerm cell histology. We compared patients in these cohorts based on the testicular tumor size.

A total of 48 patients met study criteria, 18 (37.5%) of whom had a final pathology consistent with nongerm cell histology. In general, the median tumor size was less in the nongerm cell group (11 mm vs 27 mm, p=0.001). Tumor size less than 2 cm was associated with increased likelihood of nongerm cell histology (p=0.003) with 61.9% of those with tumors less than 2 cm harboring nongerm cell tumors and therefore likely appropriate for organ-sparing surgery. A receiver operating characteristic analysis demonstrated a maximum sensitivity and specificity for selecting masses with normal tumor markers as having nongerm cell histology at a size cutoff of 18 mm.

It appears that a majority of patients with localized small testicular masses and nonelevated tumor markers will have nongerm cell histology, which makes them potentially eligible for testicular sparing surgery at centers with expertise in intraoperative frozen section analysis.