Contextualized response of carbon-use efficiency to warming at the plant and ecosystem levels

Carbon-use efficiency (CUE) has been widely used as a constant value in many earth system models to simulate how assimilated C is partitioned in ecosystems, to estimate ecosystem C budgets, and investigate C feedbacks to climate warming. Although correlative relationships from previous studies indicated that CUE could vary with temperature, and relying on a fixed CUE value could cause large uncertainty in model projections, however, due to the lack of manipulative experiment, it remains unclear how CUE at the plant (CUEp) and ecosystem (CUEe) levels respond to warming. Based on a 7-year manipulative warming experiment in an alpine meadow ecosystem on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, we quantitatively distinguished various C flux components of CUE, including gross ecosystem productivity, net primary productivity, net ecosystem productivity, ecosystem respiration, plant autotrophic respiration, and microbial heterotrophic respiration and explored how CUE at different levels responded to climate warming. We found large variations in both CUEp (0.60 to 0.77) and CUEe (from 0.38 to 0.59). The warming effect on CUEp was positively correlated with ambient soil water content (SWC) and the warming effect on CUEe was negatively correlated with ambient soil temperature (ST), but was positively correlated with warming-induced changes in ST. We also found that the direction and magnitude of the warming effects on different CUE components scaled differently with changes in the background environment, which explained the variation in CUE's warming response under environmental changes. Our new insights have important implications for reducing modelling uncertainty of ecosystem C budgets and improving our ability to predict ecosystem C-climate feedbacks under climate warming.