MD-Based Assessment of Covalent Inhibitors in Noncovalent Association Complexes: Learning from Cathepsin K as a Test...

A sufficiently stable noncovalent association complex between a covalent inhibitor and its protein target is regarded as a prerequisite for the formation of a covalent complex. As this transient form can hardly be assessed experimentally, computational modeling is required to probe the suitability of a given ligand at this particular stage. To investigate which criteria should be fulfilled by suitable candidates in a molecular dynamics (MD) assessment, a systematic study was conducted with 20 complexes of cathepsin K, a papain-like cysteine protease of pharmaceutical relevance. The covalent inhibitors in these complexes were converted to their pre-reaction states, and the resulting noncovalent complexes were subjected to MD simulations. The critical distance between the electrophilic and nucleophilic reaction partners was monitored as a potential parameter to assess the suitability for covalent bond formation. Across various warhead types, a distance between 3.6 and 4.0 Å, comparable to the sum of the generalized Born radii of carbon and sulfur, was found to be stably maintained under appropriate conditions. The protonation state of the catalytic dyad and the resulting solvation pattern dramatically affected the noncovalent binding mode and the distance of the warhead to the active site. For several complexes, fluctuations in the orientation of the warhead were observed due to torsional rotations in adjacent bonds. This observation helped to explain the gradual transitions from noncovalent to covalent complexes observed in the crystal structures of three closely related nitrile-based inhibitors. According to comparative simulations conducted for a set of 13 cathepsin S complexes, the overall findings of the study appear to be transferable to related cysteine proteases as targets of covalent inhibitors.