A National Survey of Surgeons Evaluating the Accuracy of Mediastinal Lymph Node Identification

The Commission on Cancer implemented Standard 5.8 in 2021, which requires removal of 3 mediastinal nodes and 1 hilar node with lung cancer resection. We conducted a national survey to assess whether surgeons who treat lung cancer in different clinical settings correctly identify mediastinal lymph node stations.

Cardiac or thoracic surgeons expressing interest in lung cancer surgery on the Cardiothoracic Surgery Network were asked to complete a 7-question survey assessing their knowledge of lymph node anatomy. General surgeons whose practice includes thoracic surgery were invited through American College of Surgeon's Cancer Research Program. Results were analyzed using Pearson's chi-square test. Multivariable linear regression was used to identify predictors of a higher score on the survey.

Of the 280 surgeons that responded, 86.8% were male and 13.2% were female; the median age was 50 years. Of these surgeons, 211 (75.4%) were thoracic, 59 (21.1%) were cardiac, and 10 (3.6%) were general surgeons. Surgeons were most likely to correctly identify lymph node stations 8R and 9R and least likely to correctly identify the midline pretracheal node just superior to the carina (4R). Surgeons whose practice involved a greater percentage of thoracic surgery patients and surgeons who performed a greater number of lobectomies scored higher on the lymph node assessment.

Knowledge of mediastinal node anatomy among surgeons who perform thoracic surgery is generally high, but varies by clinical setting. Efforts are under way to better educate lung cancer surgeons on nodal anatomy, and to increase adoption of Standard 5.8.