A New Validation of Montreal Cognitive Assessment on a Large Sample of Elderly Patients Undergoing Elective...

The hip and knee arthroplasties are reliable and suitable surgical procedures aimed at restoring the patients' functioning. The most representative age range for these replacement surgeries is between 65 and 84 years for females. With aging, the likelihood of developing cognitive deficits increases, and there is evidence that elderly patients undergoing surgery orthopedic are at higher risk of developing cognitive problems in the postoperative phase. The Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) is often used for cognitive evaluation, but different cut-offs and validations are available in the literature. Given the importance of the problem, in this work we studied a hospitalized population candidate for orthopedic surgery to determine a new specific validation of the MoCA to assess the risk of MCI.

We applied MoCA and Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) to a sample of 492 (333 women) hospitalized patients for knee (74%) or hip surgery. A non-parametric receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was conducted to investigate the predictive accuracy of the MoCA to assess cognitive impairment, using MMSE as the gold standard.

A score of 22.52 gives a sensitivity of 70% and a specificity of 78%. This value is providing a more coherent diagnosis with the MMSE as compared to the other cut-offs presented in the other available validations. No differences were found between patients in terms of age and gender, suggesting a general uniformity of the selected sample.

Deepening the coherence in MCI diagnosis between MMSE and the other MoCA's scoring considered, our new cut-off seems reasonably better than previous Italian validation on an elderly population in matching MMSE classification.