Efficacy of Simulator-Based Slit Lamp Training for Medical Students: A Prospective, Randomized Trial
Svenja Deuchler1,2, Yaser Abu Dail3, Frank Koch4,5
1Augenzentrum Frankfurt, Georg-Baumgarten-Straße 3, 60549, Frankfurt am Main, Germany. s.deuchler@icloud.com.
Introduction:
Simulation training has an important role in medical education. In ophthalmology, simulation-based training has been shown to be significantly effective for surgical and diagnostic training in direct and indirect ophthalmoscopy. In this study, we analysed the effects of simulator-based slit lamp training.
Methods:
In this prospective controlled trial, medical students in their eighth semester at Saarland University Medical Center (n = 24) who had attended a 1-week ophthalmological internship were randomized into two groups: The traditional group (n = 12) was examined directly after the 1-week internship; the simulator group (n = 12) was trained with the slit lamp simulator before passing an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). A masked ophthalmological faculty trainer assessed the students' slit lamp skills (maximum total score 42 points [pts]): preparation (5 pts), clinical examination (9.5 pts), assessment of findings (9.5 pts), diagnosis (3 pts), commentary on the examination approach (8 pts), measurement of structures (2 pts) and recognition of five diagnoses (5 pts). All students completed post-assessment surveys. Examination grades and survey responses were compared between the groups.
Results:
The overall performance of the slit lamp OSCE was significantly better (p < 0.001) in the simulator group than in the traditional group (29.75 [7.88] vs. 17.00 [4.75]) with significantly higher scores for the preparation and assessment of slit lamp controls (5.0 [0.0] vs. 3.0 [3.5]; p = 0.008) and localization of relevant structures (6.75 [3.13] vs. 4.0 [1.5]; p = 0.008). Consistently higher scores, but not significant, were assigned for the description of structures found (4.5 [3.38] vs. 3.25 [2.13]; p = 0.09) and the correct diagnosis (3.0 [0.0] vs. 3.0 [0.0]; p = 0.48). Surveys reflected the students' subjectively perceived knowledge gain during the simulator training for slit lamp illumination techniques (p = 0.002), recognition (p < 0.001), and assessment of the correct localization of pathologies (p < 0.001).
Conclusion:
Slit lamp examination is an important diagnostic method in ophthalmology. Simulator-based training improved students' examination techniques for localizing anatomical structures and pathological lesions. The transfer of theoretical knowledge into practice can be achieved in a stress-free atmosphere.
