Silicon isotope constraints on terrestrial planet accretion
Isaac J Onyett1, Martin Schiller2, Georgy V Makhatadze2
1Centre for Star and Planet Formation, Globe Institute, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark. isaac.onyett@sund.ku.dk.
Nature
|June 14, 2023
Summary
Primitive meteorites are not terrestrial planet building blocks. Instead, early-formed differentiated asteroids are key planetary constituents, with silicon isotope variations tracing the mixing of inner and outer Solar System materials during planet formation.
Area of Science:
- Planetary Science
- Cosmochemistry
- Isotope Geochemistry
Background:
- Understanding terrestrial planet formation requires knowledge of precursor materials.
- Nucleosynthetic variations in rocky bodies trace planetary building blocks.
- Silicon isotopes (μ30Si) are key tracers of refractory elements.
Purpose of the Study:
- To determine the nucleosynthetic composition of silicon (μ30Si) in meteorites.
- To identify the precursor materials of terrestrial planets.
- To reconstruct the accretion history of the inner Solar System.
Main Methods:
- Analysis of silicon isotope composition (μ30Si) in primitive and differentiated meteorites.
- Comparison of μ30Si values between inner and outer Solar System bodies.
- Correlation of μ30Si values with accretion ages and other isotopic tracers (Mo, Zr, Ni).
Main Results:
- Inner Solar System bodies (including Mars) show μ30Si deficits, while chondrites exhibit μ30Si excesses.
- Chondritic bodies are not primary building blocks; differentiated asteroid material is a major constituent.
- Earth's precursors incorporated ~26% μ30Si-rich outer Solar System material, while Mars formed earlier, avoiding this enrichment.
- μ30Si compositions of Mars and proto-Earth are consistent with rapid formation (<3 million years) via collisional growth and pebble accretion.
- Earth's isotopic composition aligns with pebble accretion models, considering volatility and the Moon-forming impact.
Conclusions:
- Terrestrial planet formation involved the mixing of distinct inner and outer Solar System materials.
- Early-formed differentiated asteroids, not chondrites, represent a significant component of terrestrial planets.
- Rapid accretion models explain the isotopic signatures of Mars and Earth, highlighting the role of pebble accretion.
Related Concept Videos
Isotopes
57.0K
Elements have a set number of protons that determines their atomic number (Z). For example, all atoms with eight protons are oxygen; however, the number of neutrons can vary for atoms of the same element. The sum of the number of protons and the number of neutrons is the mass number (A). Atoms with the same atomic number but different mass numbers are called isotopes. Elements can have multiple isotopes, for example, carbon-12, carbon-13, and carbon-14.
An element's atomic mass, or weight,...
An element's atomic mass, or weight,...
57.0K
Kepler's Third Law of Planetary Motion
3.4K
In the early 17th century, German astronomer and mathematician Johannes Kepler postulated three laws for the motion of planets in the solar system. In 1909, he formulated his first two laws based on the observations of his forebears, Nikolaus Copernicus and Tycho Brahe. However, in 1918, he published his third law of planetary motion, which gives a precise mathematical relationship between a planet's average distance from the Sun and the amount of time it takes to revolve around the Sun. It...
3.4K
Acceleration due to Gravity on Other Planets
4.3K
The gravitational acceleration of an object near the Earth's surface is called the acceleration due to gravity. It can be measured by conducting simple experiments on Earth. However, such an experiment is impossible to conduct on the surface of other planets.
Astronomical observations are thus used to measure the acceleration due to gravity on other planets. This can be determined by observing the effect of a planet's gravity on objects close to it. The crucial factor that helps in this...
Astronomical observations are thus used to measure the acceleration due to gravity on other planets. This can be determined by observing the effect of a planet's gravity on objects close to it. The crucial factor that helps in this...
4.3K
Isotopes and Radioisotopes
8.7K
In the early 1900s, English chemist Frederick Soddy realized that an element could have atoms with different masses that were chemically indistinguishable. These different types are called isotopes — atoms of the same element that differ in mass. Isotopes differ in mass because they have different numbers of neutrons but are chemically identical because they have the same number of protons. Soddy was awarded the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1921 for this discovery.
An isotope containing...
An isotope containing...
8.7K
Nuclear Transmutation
17.6K
Nuclear transmutation is the conversion of one nuclide into another. It can occur by the radioactive decay of a nucleus, or the reaction of a nucleus with another particle. The first manmade nucleus was produced in Ernest Rutherford’s laboratory in 1919 by a transmutation reaction, the bombardment of one type of nuclei with other nuclei or with neutrons. Rutherford bombarded nitrogen-14 atoms with high-speed α particles from a natural radioactive isotope of radium and observed...
17.6K
Isothermal Processes
3.7K
A thermodynamic process that occurs at constant temperature is called an isothermal process. Heat slowly flows into the system or out of the system to maintain thermal equilibrium. Processes involving phase changes like water evaporation into steam or freezing water into ice at a constant temperature are examples of Isothermal Processes.
An ideal gas can also undergo isothermal expansion or compression.
For example, consider 1 mole of an ideal gas inside an isolated cylinder at initial volume V...
An ideal gas can also undergo isothermal expansion or compression.
For example, consider 1 mole of an ideal gas inside an isolated cylinder at initial volume V...
3.7K


