Transgender and Gender Nonbinary Patient Experiences in the Emergency Department: A Regional Study

Transgender people experience discrimination in health care, including reports of avoiding or delaying emergency department (ED) care due to prior negative experiences, fear of discrimination, poor accommodations, and inappropriate staff behavior. Emergency physicians receive minimal training on transgender care. This study sought to understand the experience of transgender patients when visiting EDs in the Portland metro area, and the knowledge and training experience of Oregon Health & Science University (OHSU) ED staff.

Two populations were examined via survey: (1) Transgender people who accessed, or felt they should access, ED care in Portland, Oregon, in the past 5 years; and (2) OHSU ED patient-facing staff. Data were analyzed to identify trends in ED experiences, and predictors of positive experiences. Potential relationships between self-reported proficiency in transgender care and formal training experience, professional role, and duration of practice were also assessed.

Of the predictors assessed, only the opportunity to provide pronouns at check-in was associated with better perceived experiences (p<0.01). The differences between reported best and worst ED experiences were significant in all domains of perceived experiences but one (p<0.01). ED providers who had formal training were more likely to rate themselves as proficient (p<0.01). There was no relationship found between self-reported proficiency and length of practice.

This study demonstrated that there are significant differences between reported best and worst ED experiences by transgender patients, and thus areas for ED improvement. It is our recommendation that EDs provide the opportunity for patients to supply their pronouns, and offer trainings in transgender health care for employees.