Metabolic Cost of a Proposed NMES Spaceflight Countermeasure Compared to Walking in Active Adults

INTRODUCTION: Astronauts exercise to reduce microgravity-induced bone loss, but the resultant skeletal loading may not be sufficient to reduce fracture risk on an extended Mars mission. Adding additional exercise increases the risk of a negative caloric balance. Neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) induces involuntary muscle contractions, which load the skeleton. The metabolic cost of NMES is not fully understood. On Earth, walking is a common source of skeletal loading. If the metabolic cost of NMES were equal to or less than walking, it could offer a low metabolic cost option for increasing skeletal loading.METHODS:We measured the oxygen consumed and carbon dioxide produced from 10 subjects during 5-min bouts of walking at 2 mph, 3 mph, and 2 mph on a 6° incline, and of NMES to the legs at duty cycles of 1 s on and 5 s, 4 s, or 3 s off. Metabolic cost was calculated using the Brockway equation and the percent increase above resting for each NMES bout was compared to walking.RESULTS: Metabolic cost increased 64.9 ± 52.8% from rest in the most intense NMES duty cycle (1 s/3 s) and 120.4 ± 26.5%, 189.3 ± 59.5%, 281.7 ± 66.8%, for the 2 mph, 3 mph, and incline walking, respectively. The metabolic cost did not differ significantly between the three NMES duty cycles.DISCUSSION: The increase in metabolic cost of the fastest NMES bout was less than that of the slowest walk, indicating that numerous NMES bouts offer a way to increase skeletal loading at a modest metabolic cost. This might allow for more daily skeletal loading cycles, potentially further reducing bone loss.Abitante TJ, Alemi MM, Newman DJ, Duda KR.