Dissociation of recognition memory and associative learning by a restricted lesion of the chick forebrain

Bilateral lesions of a restricted part of the chick forebrain (IMHV) have been shown to impair the acquisition and retention of imprinting preferences. The present study sought to determine the effects of such lesions on an operant conditioning task in which the reward was the presentation of one of two conspicuous objects, a stuffed jungle fowl or an illuminated red box. Twelve hours after hatching 28 domestic chicks received bilateral lesions of IMHV. Thirty-two chicks served as sham-operated controls. On the following day all birds underwent two sessions of operant training. After the second session the chicks were given a preference test. In this test the reinforcing object (box or fowl) and a novel object (fowl or box, whichever had not been seen before) were simultaneously presented. One test was given 2 hr and a second 24 hr after the termination of the operant task. The lesioned birds were not impaired on the operant task or on measures of general activity. In contrast, these birds failed to show a preference for the reinforcing object whereas the sham-operated controls strongly preferred this object. These results suggest that object recognition and associative learning can be dissociated in young chicks. This dissociation is reminiscent of certain human amnesias. The lesion did not impair an expected increase in preference for the stuffed fowl which developed in all birds between the 2-hr and 24-hr preference tests.