The impact of metabolism on the adaptation of organisms to environmental change

Since Jacob and Monod's discovery of the lac operon ∼1960, the explanations offered for most metabolic adaptations have been genetic. The focus has been on the adaptive changes in gene expression that occur, which are often referred to as "metabolic reprogramming." The contributions metabolism makes to adaptation have been largely ignored. Here we point out that metabolic adaptations, including the associated changes in gene expression, are highly dependent on the metabolic state of an organism prior to the environmental change to which it is adapting, and on the plasticity of that state. In support of this hypothesis, we examine the paradigmatic example of a genetically driven adaptation, the adaptation of E. coli to growth on lactose, and the paradigmatic example of a metabolic driven adaptation, the Crabtree effect in yeast. Using a framework based on metabolic control analysis, we have reevaluated what is known about both adaptations, and conclude that knowledge of the metabolic properties of these organisms prior to environmental change is critical for understanding not only how they survive long enough to adapt, but also how the ensuing changes in gene expression occur, and their phenotypes post-adaptation. It would be useful if future explanations for metabolic adaptations acknowledged the contributions made to them by metabolism, and described the complex interplay between metabolic systems and genetic systems that make these adaptations possible.