Usefulness of smear microscopy for therapeutic decision-making in patients with infectious keratitis

To determine the usefulness of smears in the diagnosis of infectious keratitis by comparing smears and 2 different culture methods.

Retrospective, observational study.

The foci of 73 patients diagnosed with infectious keratitis at Hiroshima University Hospital between July 2011 and September 2015 were abraded, and smear microscopy and culturing were performed. The microorganism detection rates and other parameters were compared.

Microorganisms were detected in 47 of 73 specimens. Microorganisms were identified in 32 of 69 cases cultured on plain medium (detection rate, 46.4%) compared with 22 of 61 cases cultured on swab transport medium (detection rate, 36.1%). There was no significant difference in the microbial detection rate between the plain medium method and the swab transport medium method (P = 0.23). Smear microscopy and culture findings were concordant in 21 (28.8%) cases, and different microorganisms were detected in 9 cases. In 17 cases, the culture was negative, despite the presence of microorganisms on smear microscopy, and in 7 cases, the culture was positive, despite the absence of microorganisms on smear microscopy. The positivity rate of microbial detection was significantly higher when no antimicrobial agents had been administered previously (odds ratio 7.50, P = 0.017).

Smear microscopy of abrasions from lesions is useful for the initiation of treatment for infectious keratitis. However, culture studies should be conducted at the same time to confirm antimicrobial sensitivity. If possible, smear microscopy should be performed before the initiation of antimicrobial therapy.