Fast-evolving nuclear genes as barcoding markers for black flies (Diptera: Simuliidae) in Thailand

Rapid and accurate identification is a prerequisite for the study of all aspects of species, particularly for pests and vectors. Black flies are economically significant blood-sucking insects, as many species are pests and vectors that transmit parasites to humans and other animals. We examined the efficiency of two fast-evolving nuclear genes, elongator complex protein 1 (ECP1) and big zinc finger (BZF), for identifying 13 nominal species in three species-groups of black flies, the Simulium multistriatum, S. striatum, and S. tuberosum groups, in Thailand where the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase I (COI) gene has not been successful for differentiating many nominal species. ECP1 gene sequences were highly effective for identification, with >96% (181 of 188) of the specimens correctly identified. Unsuccessful identifications based on ECP1 were between S. nakhonense and S. chiangmaiense, which are members of the S. striatum species-group, whereas all identifications of nominal species of the S. multistriatum and S. tuberosum species-groups were successful. In contrast, BZF had successful rates for the S. striatum species-group, with >93% (71 of 76) of the specimens correctly identified. This gene also successfully assigned unknown larvae of the S. striatum group to species. Phylogenetic analyses and molecular species delimitations based on the BZF gene uncovered cryptic diversity in two nominal species, S. nakhonense and S. wangkwaiense, which will require resolution through further study.