Characterization of Six Diamide Insecticides on Ryanodine Receptor: Resistance and Species Selectivity

Ryanodine receptor (RyR) has been used as an insecticide target to control many destructive agricultural pests. The effectiveness of these insecticides has been limited by the spread of resistance mutations identified in pest RyRs, but the detailed molecular impacts of the individual mutations on the activity of different diamide compounds have not been fully explored. We created five HEK293 cell lines stably expressing wild type rabbit RyR1, wild type Spodoptera frugiperda RyR (Sf RyR), or Sf RyR carrying different resistance mutations, including G4891E, G4891E/I4734M, and Y4867F, respectively. R-CEPIA1er, a genetically encoded fluorescent protein, was also introduced in these cell lines to report the Ca²⁺ concentration in the endoplasmic reticulum. We systematically characterized the activities of six commercial diamide insecticides against different RyRs using the time-lapse fluorescence assay. Among them, cyantraniliprole (CYAN) displayed the highest activity against all three resistant Sf RyRs. The good performance of CYAN was confirmed by the toxicity assay using gene-edited Drosophila expressing the mutant RyRs, in which CYAN showed the lowest LD₅₀ value for the double resistant mutant. In addition, we compared their acitivty between mammalian and insect RyRs and found that flubendiamide has the best insect-selectivity. The mechanism of the anti-resistance property and selectivity of the compounds was proposed based on the structural models generated by homology modeling and molecular docking. Our findings provide insights into the mechanism of insect resistance and guidance for developing effective RyR agonists that can selectively target resistant pests.