Student and instructor perspectives following a virtual objective structured clinical examination

In March 2020, COVID-19 public health restrictions impeded in-person clinical assessment. In response, a dental hygiene program administered a virtual objective structured clinical exam (vOSCE) using Zoom to assess student competency in performing a health history. This study aimed to explore the vOSCE experience from both student and clinical instructor perspectives.

This 2-part cross-sectional study gathered student and clinical instructor perceptions of the vOSCE. Forty-two students were invited to complete an online questionnaire. Basic descriptive statistics reporting percentages were tabulated. Twelve clinical instructors were invited to participate in focus groups, which were audiorecorded and transcribed verbatim. Qualitative data were analysed using inductive thematic analysis.

Questionnaires were received from 23 (55%) students. Students supported (91%) the vOSCE experience and believed it assessed their knowledge (87%), their ability to complete a health history (91%), and ability to communicate effectively (87%). Students reported high agreement (87%) with how the Zoom platform facilitated the examination. Some students (35%) felt the vOSCE was more stressful than an in-person OSCE. However, 43% indicated it wasn't more stressful. Focus groups with clinical instructors revealed perspectives on using vOSCEs, which were captured under 4 themes: preparation, assessment suitability, authenticity, and future considerations.

Based on student and instructor perspectives, vOSCEs could be a viable alternative to in-person OSCEs for health history evaluations. As technology applications continue to emerge for conducting virtual examinations, there may be increased use of and ease of use with a virtual platform to conduct other types of clinical evaluations.