Host-utilization differences between larval and nymphal deer ticks in northeastern U.S. sites enzootic for Borrelia...

In the northeastern U.S., Borrelia burgdorferi sensu stricto, the agent of Lyme disease, is maintained between vertebrate hosts and subadult deer ticks (the northern clade of Ixodes scapularis, formerly known as Ixodes dammini). Theoretical arguments suggest that the force of transmission would be greatest when infected nymphal ticks focus their bites on the same host as the uninfected larvae. Stage-specific differences in host utilization would reduce the force of transmission, but to date such differences remain understudied. We determined the host utilization differences of larval and nymphal deer ticks using bloodmeal analysis of host-seeking nymphs and adults collected from 5 field sites in New England. Matched cohorts of ticks (nymphs=506, adults=451), i.e. ticks that had fed during the same summer season, were used to control for yearly host population variations. Infection status of all ticks was determined by real time PCR. Nymphal deer ticks were more likely to have fed on birds and sciurids (13% vs 3%, and 41% vs 9%, respectively p<0.001) and larvae were more likely to have fed on shrews (26% vs 3%, p<0.001). Similarly, ticks that had fed on a mouse or a shrew as larvae were likely to become infected (OR= 3.195, 95% CI [1.9, 5.1] and OR=2.5[1.6,3.8] respectively), and they were positively associated with infection prevalence at our sites. However, very few nymphs fed on shrews, and they were not associated with infection, raising the question of how uninfected shrews acquire infection each year. Sciurids did not appear to contribute to the enzootic cycle at our sites, which may be due to the low numbers of larvae that fed on them. Sciurid-fed ticks of either stage were not associated with infection. Both stages of ticks were less likely to be infected if they had fed on deer (OR=0.08 [0.02.0.3] and OR=0.4 [0.2,0.7] tested as nymphs and adults, respectively) and thus deer likely served to reduce the force of transmission at our sites. Site-specific analysis of differential host utilization by subadult deer ticks may contribute to appropriate targeting of interventions and thereby promote reducing risk of acquiring Lyme disease and the other deer tick-transmitted infections.