Image-defined risk factors in localized thoracic neuroblastoma and ganglioneuroma

The pretreatment International Neuroblastoma Risk Group Staging System (INRGSS) discriminates localized tumors L1/L2 depending on the absence/presence of image-defined risk factors (IDRFs) at diagnosis. Referring to this new staging system, we assessed initial imaging of localized thoracic neuroblastoma (NB) and ganglioneuroma (GN) and the extent of initial tumor resection.

Patients with localized thoracic NB/GN from the German clinical trials NB97 and NB2004 were included. Imaging at diagnosis and operative reports were reviewed retrospectively. IDRFs were assessed centrally and correlated to International Neuroblastoma Staging System (INSS) stage and extent of tumor resection. Additionally, we analyzed data on surgery-related complications.

Imaging series of 88 patients were available for central review. In 18 children, no IDRF was present, 28 exhibited one IDRF, 42 two or more IDRFs, resulting in 70 patients with L2 disease. The most frequently observed IDRF was encasement of any vessel (n = 38). Initial surgical resection was aimed for in 45 patients (L1: n = 11; L2: n = 34). Complete and gross total resection rates were higher children with L2 NB (n = 8/25 L1, n = 17/25 L2 vs. n = 2/15 L1, n = 13/15 L2, respectively). The proportion of surgical complications was very similar between INRGSS L1 and L2 (n = 4/11 vs. n = 17/34). All complications were manageable, and no surgery-related deaths were observed.

In this retrospective cohort, the extent of resection and the rate of surgical complications did not differ substantially between patients classified as L1/L2, indicating that INRGSS L2 does not equate unresectability. It appeared that individual IDRFs differ in value. Larger studies are needed to assess the significance and therapeutic/prognostic impact of such findings.