Is There a Need to "Modernize" and "Simplify" the Diagnostic Criteria of Protein-Energy Wasting?

Protein energy wasting(PEW) is a term that most nephrologists used to define nutritional disorders in patients with acute kidney injury and chronic kidney disease. Although this nomenclature is well implemented in the field of nephrology, the use of other terms such as cachexia or malnutritionin the majority of chronic diseases can induce confusion regarding the definition and interpretation of these terms. There is ample evidence in the literature that the pathways involved in cachexia/malnutrition and PEW are common. However, in kidney diseases, there are pathophysiological conditions such as accumulation of uremic toxins, and the use of dialysis, which may induce a phenotypic specificity justifying the original term PEW. In light of the latest epidemiologic studies, the criteria for PEW used in 2008 probably need to be updated. The objective of this review is to summarize the main mechanisms involved in cachexia/malnutrition and PEW. We discuss the need to modernize and simplify the current definition and diagnostic criteria of PEW. We consider the interest of proposing a specific nomenclature of PEW for children and elderly patients with kidney diseases.