Consumer-Led Investigation into Potential Issues That Arise When Testing Dairy Matrixes for Gluten With the NIMA
Tricia Thompson1, Adrian Rogers2, Johnna Perry3
1Gluten Free Watchdog, LLC, 348 Summer St, Manchester, MA 01944, United States.
Background:
Some consumers with celiac disease use personal, point-of-use gluten detection devices to test food. False-positive results may occur due to sampling, matrix effects, and sensor issues.
Objective:
The purpose of the present study was to determine if the positive gluten results some users were obtaining when testing cream cheese and materials of similar consistency were false positives and, if so, what might be causing them to occur.
Methods:
Cream cheese, soft cheese, and yogurt were tested for gluten using the Ridascreen Gliadin R7001 sandwich R5 ELISA and the Ridascreen Gliadin R7021 competitive R5 ELISA. Two test portions were taken, extracted, and tested from each homogenized material. Materials were also analyzed for gluten using a NIMA sensor, a personal, point-of-use gluten detection device. Multiple test portion weights were tested beginning at 0.13 to 0.17 g (the ideal weight of the test portion according to the NIMA sensor development team).
Results:
Using the sandwich R5 ELISA and the competitive R5 ELISA, all materials tested below the lower LOD for gluten. Using a NIMA sensor, as the weight of the test portion tested increased, sensor results went from no gluten found, to gluten found, to no test result.
Conclusion:
The gluten found results using the NIMA sensor are likely false positives that appear to correspond with the weight and volume of the material tested, as well as the viscosity. There is also an apparent disconnect between the gluten found result reported by the sensor and an interpretation of the lateral flow device (LFD) strip result when assessed by eye which should also be taken into account. Ideally, NIMA sensor users should be advised on the weight amount of material to analyze and test portions should be weighed before being used with the NIMA sensor. However, this is not a practical solution when testing in many environments, including restaurants.
Highlights:
Slight variations in weight and volume of test materials can result in false positive results when testing dairy matrixes for gluten using the Nima sensor.
