Review: Use of assisted reproduction in seasonal-calving dairy herds

A unique aspect of seasonal-calving pasture-based systems of dairy production is the intense focus placed on achieving a concentrated herd-calving period in late winter and early spring. Hence, excellent reproductive performance is required during a short breeding period. A concentrated calving period also produces a problem in the form of a large number of male dairy calves being born at the same time; as these calves have little economic value due to poor beef merit, they present a potential welfare concern. A solution exists in the form of sex-sorted semen, but this is typically associated with poorer pregnancy per artificial insemination, and hence, the use of sex-sorted semen must be carefully considered. The logical strategy to use sex-sorted semen is to target the best genetic merit dams in the herd to generate replacement heifers, thereby accelerating herd genetic gain. On the other hand, if all dairy farmers adopt such a strategy, there will be a corresponding reduction in elite genetic merit male dairy calves being born, potentially reducing availability of the next generation of future bulls to be used for artificial insemination. Use of in vitro embryo production on elite dairy donors could avoid this problem by acting as a multiplier, potentially in tandem with Y-sorted semen to skew the offspring sex ratio towards more male calves. Use of sex-sorted semen on the best genetic merit dams can also facilitate a marked increase in the usage of beef semen on any dams that are deemed unsuitable for sex-sorted semen. The use of "beef on dairy" requires selection of beef bulls that generate offspring with traits that meet the key requirements of both the dairy farmer (e.g., gestation length and calving ease) and the beef farmer that must be motivated to purchase the calves (e.g., growth rate, age at slaughter, carcass value). Beef breed dams that have elite genetic merit for these traits could also be considered for in vitro embryo production, potentially in tandem with Y-sorted semen, to facilitate genetic gain for the growing "beef-on-dairy" market. It is possible to transfer a beef embryo (75-100% beef breed genetics) into dairy dams that are not required to generate replacements, but this is likely to remain a niche practice as there are many barriers to widespread adoption. Such combinations of assisted reproduction have the potential to improve the efficiency and sustainability metrics of seasonal-calving pasture-based dairy herds.